Infraction: 7. Do not beg for hand-holding.
Message to User:
You'd "like an overall comparison wihich showed the Top 10 or so trinkets" and I'd like a pony. With all the infractions you've got, you should have known well enough that asking for others to make you a list is going to get you a whole month off. (Edit: some infractions have expired it seems, he lives to post another day.)
The on use Str, and Agi, procs for the Tol Barad trinkets are current underbudget which causes them to lose a lot of value vs other 359 ilvl trinkets. As far as I know this issue hasn't been addressed on the PTR which means it probably won't make it into the next patch. Hopefully Blizzard recognizes this issue at some point and buffs the trinkets.
Edit: Took out the DMC: Hurricane part since someone covered it much better than I did.
Yes, but what about the non-epic trinkets? Will Impatience of Youth be better of them when 4.0.6 comes?
I can confirm that DMC: Hurricane is an outstanding trinket. Over a 5 minute span on the raiding dummy on live, the nature proc alone accounted for just over 3.9% of total damage. Has anyone done testing to evaluate this trinket on the PTR? My concern is the fix on SoC might have an impact. Also curious to see how one would model a comparison between DMC: Hurricane and Impatience of Youth, considering the buff to mastery.
I'd like an overall comparison wihich showed the Top 10 or so trinkets, epic & non-epic. I know that the OP rules out BiS, but there is also mentioned the discussion of the sometimes (very) different trinket mechanics.
A proper weighting akin to some other classes' topics, would be of great help when deciding what is and what is not an upgrade in that slot.