Infraction: 6. Do not post unless you have something new and worthwhile to say.
Message to User:
When involving yourself in a subject which is under debate, please use hard evidence to back up your suppositions. The person you were responding to apparently has run simcraft numbers to back up his argument. I would suggest either using Simcraft, spreadsheet data, or extensive personal testing in controlled conditions as a reference before you dispute his claim. What you cited seems very anecdotal and ultimately not very useful to answering anyone's questions.
Ever since the Heroic Strike nerf in 4.0.6, Incite has been greatly devalued. Currently, taking a point from Deep Wounds and putting it into Incite is a dps loss. How much of a loss will depend on your gear, but for me, simcraft says it's about 300dps down, which is significant.
I disagree from trial perspective. Deep Wounds is nice, but when I look at my logs, I'm using Heroic Strike very frequently (thanks to raid damage giving me lots of rage income). I usually only use HS during Colossus Smash, so the extra 5% crit and 100% probability of a 2nd crit is very nice, because I can often get 2 HS's in during a CS rotation.