Infraction: 6. Do not post unless you have something new and worthwhile to say.
Message to User:
Ok, give it a rest with the e-peen battling between the lines. No one cares about your personal disagreements here and talking on behalf of the community doesn't really get you any points. If you want to discuss this sort of stuff with an individual, take it to PMs.
Thanks for letting us know about your upcoming schedule for content though, it was pleasant to read.
Cut this sort of crap out, or simply stop posting here.
I didn't comment like I was there, read (and reread) my posts, since I explicitly stated that. You seem to think I'm posting about heroics when I explicitly stated I do not have experience with heroics and the only comments I made regarding heroic content pertains to the logs, videos, and mumble/vent/skype which are all available from PTR kills and testing. With the available media the points I made are accurate.
Considering your status as (what I would assume) the RL of BL, and an individual who has all 4 tank classes currently at 7/7h (though only 1 pre-nerf 7/7h) I would assume you would stress the importance of 'optimal' over 'capable'.
Your previous posts in this thread have been exactly what I specified, and you even agreed to in your post. You post information that we already *knew* and already had logs, sims, and actual experience to back up and then placed your personal opinion on specific aspects of the class (which, again, is fine - but don't make the mistake of thinking just because you are in top 15 guild that your opinion invalidates actual finding proven true by multiple posters).
For the vast majority of this thread the normal modes which will be released next week is going to be 'end game' and it's going to have an impact on what class they decide to play, so yes, they are worth discussing and it is valid speculation. In 2 weeks most of us (myself included) will be working on heroic content. If you want to limit this thread to what you consider to be 'high end' versus what most of the topic contributors feel to be 'high end' then it would be you and Wakez replying back and forth.
Your ad hominem attacks aside and regardless of how you personally feel about the math and theory crafting performed on this forum and other forums which pool information here, they are accurate more often than not. While your personal opinions may contradict our findings, there has been numerous proof (via logs and multiple posters experience) to back up the math and theory craft on this site. The end result is that there are multiple ways to reach a desired result, but you contribute your opinion to the thread as if your way is the best way and all other ways are inferior.