Infraction: 2. All opinions should be stated as succinctly as possible.
Message to User:
Instead of posting a new post, please edit your existing post if it's still the last one in the thread and there has been less than a day between your posts.
For disc, absolutely yes, I would rather have the furious weapon. For holy, valanyr(minus proc) edges out the furious mace, but not by a ton. If I had to choose one or the other to use all the time and couldn't have both, I would choose the furious weapon; on the whole, it is a better weapon.
What? You'd rather have 18 Stamina, 16 MP5, and a 5 spell power blue gem socket than 8 int, 47 Crit and 46 Haste? That's a significantly smaller budget of stats, and in lower quality ones, unless you're talking about which item is better for pvp healing.
In practice, you still need both and you still end up using the furious/hard mode ulduar weapon more than valanyr to control the proc.