Infraction: 6. Do not post unless you have something new and worthwhile to say.
Message to User:
You express a lot of certitude about the value of a trinket based solely on how it ranks for your gear and spec. You can probably assert that it's not good for everyone, but you need to provide a little more support for your claims if you're going to claim that it's no good for anyone.
Mirror is indeed better than Wrathstone. Sure, less Crit, but considerably more Average AP.
Banner also has considerably more AP. Not sure if it has enough more AP to compensate the trade of 108 crit to 84 ArP...
My guess is... did you Click CalcAtributes after equiping, setting your talents and rotation? Shandra's default profile is a MM hunter.
In no way is Mirror of Truth better than Wrathstone. It's not even better than Bandit's Insignia. In the gear planner on my sheet, Mirror is not even listed. My Bandit's Insignia is #10 and The Banner of Victory is #6 wiith a dps gain of 52. Banner is better than Greatness.
Of course it all depends on your spec and the other gear you have equipped. They all work together but I still say that there is no way the Mirror can be better than Wrathstone.