Infraction: 7. Do not beg for hand-holding.
Message to User:
Agi vs ArP has been discussed already. Search and read before posting.
I have a question: Rawr & Toskk disagree about Agi vs. ArP, which do I trust?
Here's gear since I probably logged in PvP gear:
Profiler - Wowhead
Cat form stats (with my own MotW):
Hit: 264 (~8%)
Exp: 122 (~6.00%)
ArP: 245 (17.51%)
Has: 591 (0.81s)
In both Rawr and Toskk's I enter my appropriate stats and select the raid buffs I typically get.
For Rawr I made a separate profile and switched all gems to ArP, and it indicates a ~50 DPS loss. Also tried conserving yellow socket bonuses, approximately the same DPS loss.
Toskk's is kind enough to recommend switching to ArP gems, predicting a ~70 DPS gain. Toskk's even ranks Strength above Agility since I can exceed the crit cap by ~2% if everything procs at once.
This is super-confounding since as I understand Rawr is built on Toskk's. Which do I pt my faith (gold) in?