Infraction: 10. Do not back-seat moderate.
Message to User:
It's upsetting that you felt the need to post a giant quote and backseat moderate instead of reporting it.
It's upsetting that you guys only needed to look one page back...
Not quite. The fact that it only procs off of Auto-attacks, SS physical, BS, and PS remains true, yes. The fact that the proc chance is 2 ppm (11.33%) remains true, yes. But the line at the end of that post - that heroic Bryntroll is inferior to heroic Cryptmaker and normal Bryntroll is inferior to normal Shadow's Edge and normal Cryptmaker may or may not still hold - and preliminary math is showing it doesn't.
Due to sub-speccing into Frost, Bryntroll gets a large boost. 20% more auto-attacks translates into about 5 more proc opportunities per minute. As well, since we (once again) won't be taking Reaping, that's an additional 3 proc opportunities per minute. Black Ice is pretty straight-forward in how it affects it: 10% more proc damage.
All in all, the weapon gets a modest boost, and at current gear levels, Bryntroll will pull ahead. In BiS, heroic Cryptmaker would win, but that's rather irrelevant due to the fact that for BiS heroic Glorenzelg (and, obviously, Shadowmourne) is going to beat both handily (due to raw ilvl and weapon dps, everything else aside).
When I have the time, I'll throw up the 3.3.3 BiS lists/stat weights/etc, but it's not a huge priority as little enough changes.