Infraction: 8. All accounts must have a valid WoW profile.
Message to User:
There is no such character on that realm, fix your profile. We don't allow anonymous posting here.
SparkDKTank, you are discussing blood shield numbers while not even mentioning avoidance, while your gear is fully stacked towards avoidance (with some stam stacking, not sure why). Does this not seem a bit strange to you? Additionally (I cannot access the paladin's armory page for some reason) the warrior is completely stacked for mastery (~21 mastery, and 24% avoidance, vs your 14.67 mastery and 31% avoidance. So yes, if you stack for avoidance and the warrior stacks for mitigation, he will mitigate more damage. I am still, apparently, missing the point of your post.