Infraction: 6. Do not post unless you have something new and worthwhile to say.
Message to User:
The post you replied to was bad enough, but if your answer consists of "sim it", then you should be reporting, not replying.
but in both is the molten oder mage Amor (critcap) better than frost amor
Yes, the weights would suggest that, but 5% of either stat is a lot--enough that the linearized weights (which are what we have) no longer apply. The result is suggestive, though, and I think it would be valid to sim Molten or Mage armor as a check.